Trew is good stuff, but as far as I am concerned the waterproofing material they use is not the best, it's a standard polyurethane membrane which is very durable and reliable, just not very breathable. Bombproof but sweaty ski-bum wear.
My take on the jackets at this point is that there are major brands, like Patagonia, Arcteryx, Marmor, Mountain Hardware, etc, that all make their stuff in China and all with slightly varying degrees of quality and materials. The difference is mainly in the type of fabrics and details of the fit. A few smaller brands, such as FlyLow and/or Trew who got on the NeoShell bandwagon are approaching the same level as the big companies. Their early efforts were substandard (the original LabCoat by FlyLow had a fugly and primitive boxy fit, coupled with a well-known fabric delamination problem at the pockets. But thanks to it being one of the first NeoShell jackets with a powder skirt and a well-thought design tweaks where it counts (inner pockets, and chin area) it sold like hotcakes. I have that jacket (and still love it), FlyLow glued back the delay fabric, so now it looks fashionably "ski-bum". As an aside, Patagonia or Arcteryx would never have allowed that to happen, and would not sent that "fixed" jacket back to a customer. I looked at Strafe jackets, they look like also-runs to me. The quality is not better than FlyLow and the design is slicker, but decidedly less functional.
The small company that does stand out for me is Westcomb, but that is because they own a very high-end factory in Vancouver, BC with a long history of manufacturing high-end technical garments for others that allows them to make pieces with quantifiably better quality than even Arcteryx or Patagonia (with a high price to match, and with a noticeable concentration on the weight-weenie backcountry market).
The jury is out for me on a newer players like FreerideSystems. I have not seen their jackets in person, only in pictures (and none of them shows the seams, of the fit of the seam sealing tape) so I cannot vouch either way, but I don't necessarily yet see the reason why they should be better than the big league guys (with all due apologies to theBestSkier, who has been a great presence on this board). All jackets don't fail by developing holes, or ripping stitches. It's always either DWR wearing off in an abrasion area, the seam sealing tape starting to peel off, fabric glued on next to a zipper starting to delaminate, the velcro cuff starting to get undone, liner fabric developing pills, etc. Getting those things right takes either the right manufacturing partner or time to iron out the kinks. The jury is still out for me.