Really hard to argue with the new OB...we didn't need the space and liked the drivability of the Alltrack..it was a tough choice.
I did not test drive the Alltrack. Partly because I knew I would like it. The dieselgate thing kind of bugged me, but primarily, I just did not want another German car, or any domestic cars. Really wanted something AWD from Japan. I'd never owned a Subaru (or VW) and had been interested in getting one for years. Of course, my next car might be a Golf GTi.
We have 10,000 miles on the OB in 3 months and are very happy with it. Fuel mileage hand calculated is just a bit over 27 mpg. I hoped for closer to 30, but other than that, we are totally satisfied, and then some.
I guess I should write "German brand" or "Japanese brand". The OB is made in Indiana. I forget the %US content but its pretty high. The factory where they are made was used for a dozen years+- until recently, to build Toyota Camrys as Toyota was unable to keep up with demand. I suspect Subaru picked up a few good ideas from the Toyota builds. Fasteners to electronics, materials, panel gaps....etc. all are very impressive, especially considering it is a "value" and not "premium" car.
Already checking into swapping it for an 18 3.6 Limited or Touring. I figure that means we are satisfied.