thanks to everyone so far on this thread. I am doing the research myself this summer on Alltrack vs Outback. Going to keep my 07 Yukon XL, but 10 years and 131K later time for a different daily driver.
IMO a long test drive in each should reveal which one you like most. The VW has a fantastic engine and trans, and can be found with a manual trans. The Outback has an exceptional AWD system and feels light on its feet. Both are great cars and should return close to 30 mpg.